To My Anonymous Ranter:
So I got this about an article I posted. I want to address it, but I have to do it here, rather than directly, since this was an anon:
post/16006113317: “even if one of them is just conservative in appearance” Wait a minute. You’re saying even if I choose to wear certain clothes, it’s being ‘conservative’? I understood ‘liberal’ as having the freedom to decide what I should wear! I’m a prude if I wear a burka, a slut if I wear a bikini? I’m NOT saying Mahdy is wrong or you are, I just want to let you know, it’s possible to dress ‘conservative’ and not be forced into it by ‘Islamists’. Why is this box stopping me from typing
the box will not stop me. What I’m trying to say: why are Muslim women who dress accordingly by their own choice ‘conservative’ and ‘oppressed’ and living under the ‘growing influence of Islamism’? Where did the word ‘Islamist’ even come from?Eh? If by that you mean the corrupt, misogynistic, secretly sex-obsessed, patriarchal, wealthy, homophobic group of men in power, then yes, it’s a bad thing. But if you’re suggesting ‘Islamism’ is Islam, you’re quite wrong.
me again. A true believer would never use the name of religion to test a woman’s virginity, not force her dress how he wanted, nor beat her, nor NOTHING. It pains me to see the name of my beautiful religion used as a terrible thing: “Islamism” “Islamist” “Islamic Terrorism” “Islamic Fundamentalist”. Is not a ‘fundamentalist’ one who adheres to the fundamentals? In that case, he would truly be the best Muslim and women would be on the highest level to him.
First, I would like to say those were not my words. Maybe the source got lost in the reblogs, but I lifted the article from Mona Eltahawy for the Guardian. What she asserts is her opinion. And yes, I did choose this article from others I read on Mahdy, and I did so because I thought it addressed some issues very concisely.
Women should choose to dress as they want and do what they want - I hold to that. Whether they want to wear a burqa or niqab, bikini or nothing. Part of Mahdy’s message (as I’ve interpreted it) was that it is her choice - her body. She should choose, and no one else.
I do not, and have never suggested that Islamism (under your defined terms) is Islam.
And I cannot defend the word “fundamentalist”, or what it has come to mean. Maybe one day it will be reappropriated, like the word “terrorist” (a word with positive meaning during the French Revolution). But for now, it is what it is. Every religion has a blemish of this.
I agree, a true believer in any higher power should not do as man does, but we (in all our structures) are human and we err. I do not speak for whoever it is you really want to be heard by, I can’t tell you who has twisted and contorted the vocabulary of Islam, but I can tell you that there people on all sides of this issue who take offense to the deviations. And inshallah, one day there will be understanding.







